I’m trying to confirm the authenticity of the screenshot below (I couldn’t recreate the problem myself). This picture has been bouncing all over the Internet as of last night – over at Reddit, Mashable, The Sly Oyster, etc.. If this is true, someone at Warner Music Group is going to have a hard time explaining this mistake:

Here depicts Death Cab For Cutie‘s website, which had posted a video of Death Cab For Cutie playing a song, and the video was removed by Death Cab For Cutie’s record label for copyright infringement. While it’s easy to develop a theory as to why this might happen (fan posts a music video of DCFC they recorded off of VH1, DCFC out of laziness links to that instead of posting their own, WMG files copyright claim to YouTube, YouTube complies, DCFC doesn’t change their link), it does serve as a poetic depiction of the ongoing debate artist’s interests versus record company’s interests. It also serves as fairly positive evidence that bands are okay with their songs getting onto YouTube, and it’s the record companies that are trying to squelch these postings. Given the nature of a record contract, that makes a great deal of sense. They would be the ones making royalties off of sales of these videos. And to some extent – perhaps under a labor theory of property (as we’re learning about these days) – they are also the ones that produce, record, and fund these videos. But it’d be a pretty boring video without the Gibbard/Walla love. Shouldn’t they have a say as to where their songs can and cannot be posted?
Perhaps this is an indication of a trend a few of us have been detecting over the past few years. Increasingly, artists are taking issues of production and promotion into their own hands. An action like this shows what kind of problems might arrise when two parties claim ownership to the same property. As more and more people begin to produce records on their own, and more and more times the artist and the record company’s interest feel at odds, the less relevant record companies feel.
Something to chew on for your morning commute.